Shopping for a new phone, only prerequisites are that it be durable, and hopefully work well with my D3 and cd btb-200. Which phones are people having the most success with? I understand that theres a topic about this, but searching every page becomes tedious and frustrating.

Here is the thread you need to read.

CD-BTB200 & Bluetooth Phone Compatibility Guide

I have a Verizon LG 8350 and it works great once you figure out how to properly get it loaded. However I had to add my contacts one at a time.