Search Archive

Poor routing, out of date data

By MChance000 · Apr 25, 2006in Problems/Troubleshooting💬 92 posts👁️ 21,177 views
Page 4 of 4
Posted Jun 03, 2006 · 14:33 UTC#76
Okay, this is for those that think gps and routing is a perfect science, I plotted a route from my house in the San Francisco peninsula to UCSD.

Yahoo Maps 496.1 miles 6 hours 53 min
Mapquest 497.49 miles 7 hours 38 min
Mapblast 488.4 miles 7 hours 9 min
Streets & Trips 505.6 miles 8 hours 9 min
Pocketmap 499.6 miles 7 hours 2 min
AVIC-Z1 (30/45/65) 496 miles 9 hours 8 min
AVIC-Z1 (35/45/70) 496 miles 8 hours 30 min

The AVIC reports the most time, they all take a little different route in the LA area so the difference in time. I suspect the AVIC maps database does not account for a large section of interstate 5 has speed limit of 75 mph, thus the time is longer


This is not realy correct test. Because there is not many options how to get from you home to San Francisco. Try something local.
I plotted route from my home to my work

Avic - 18.9 miles 48 minutes
Tom Tom 12.6 miles 26 minutes
MIcrosoft Map Point - 13 miles 23 minutes.

I think Avic can't even calculate right route becouse it takes average speed limits into accaunt instead of real speed limits.
Posted Jun 03, 2006 · 19:12 UTC#77
I think you missed the point, that was not a test. With a straight forward route with as little option as possible, the different software should come up with very similar results - that was my point, no option, no side street, no shortcut.
Posted Jun 12, 2006 · 01:57 UTC#78
Anyone want to give a update on thier z1? Hows it going so far, is it still having problems, or is it accurate still? Also has anyone called or emailed pioneer or teleatlas about this problem?
Posted Jun 19, 2006 · 19:44 UTC#79
I have returned my Avic-z1 for full refund. Got instead Kenwood ddx-8017 plus KNA-G510.
Sound quality of Kenwood much better then Pioneer. Navigation is not as easy to use as Avic-z1, map has not as many details as Avic-z1, but routing is much better. So far, I have no bad routes, no wrong turns and missing POI. However, I have to admit Pioneer is more user friendly and Avic-z1 navigation has more futures then Kenwood
Posted Jun 19, 2006 · 21:32 UTC#80
Here's my update....

I know I'm gonna be called a Pioneer fan-boy for this but I still REALLY love this unit. Here's what I did:

Bought a Magellan 860T
Navigation was OK but it would lock up and occassionally in the middle of a route it would tell me "no route to destination" and cancel the route, it also has TDS (sp?) traffic info which was useless, never told me anything...so

I returned it and bought a Garmin 2730 because it does XM traffic routing plus XM radio and it can play music and nav at the same time unlike the Magellan. The unit works well enough but it is constantly turning me in the wrong directions or taking me extremely round about ways.

Went to my in-laws this weekend and decided to try my father in laws..I can't remember the name right now, it was a brand I hadn't come accross before and according to my F-I-L it got great reviews. This thing would constantly tell me to make uturns if I didn't like the route it was taking me.

The one thing these other 3 units did do better is estimate the travel time. My pioneer unit is off my almost 25-30% on every trip which is irritating. However, in every other aspect it has outperformed these other GPS units.

That said, I have no idea how it pairs up to other full blown in dash nav units like Alpines or Kenwoods, but I still am not getting the errors on my unit that others are reporting.
Posted Jun 19, 2006 · 21:58 UTC#81
I went in and changed my default speeds for the different types of roads and it made a HUGE difference in the estimated time accuracy.
Posted Jun 21, 2006 · 00:10 UTC#82
03Aviator said:
I went in and changed my default speeds for the different types of roads and it made a HUGE difference in the estimated time accuracy.


What settings did you use? I tried my best guess at the actual speeds -- 79, 64, 39 -- and I didn't see any difference.
Posted Jun 21, 2006 · 00:16 UTC#83
Changing speed settings affects only ETA and makes no difference for routing itself.
Posted Nov 16, 2007 · 18:28 UTC#84
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.
PIONEERS ROUTING LOGIC IS BAD.

ITS NOT THE TELEATLAS MAPS!

I HAVE A MIO C310X ($150) WITH THE SAME MAPS AND IT KILLS MY Z2 IN TERMS OF EFFICENT ROUTING!

MORE THAN PISSED!

THANKS PIONEER!
Posted Nov 16, 2007 · 18:36 UTC#85
We should be DEMANDING the following things from Pioneer:

1. NEW ROUTING ALGORYTHM!

2. Updated maps. (At no charge)

3. DIVX and MP3 on DVD data discs.

Anything else?

AVIC ROUTING SUCKS MORE THAN ANY OTHER GPS EVER!

:evil:
Posted Nov 16, 2007 · 20:49 UTC#86
You should write a strongly worded letter. I am sure they will listen
Posted Nov 16, 2007 · 23:50 UTC#87
Amen brother! Sold mine. I like to drop in from time to time to see if they will fix this issue. Pioneer will not even acknowledge they have a routing problem. Call them and complain you will be disappointed. They told me 20 to 30 miles out of my way was acceptable. I responded not on three dollar a gallon gas its not. Good luck
Posted Nov 16, 2007 · 23:53 UTC#88
whtcrxghst said:
You should write a strongly worded letter. I am sure they will listen
By the way this is the normal response you get from some of the members on this board.
Posted Nov 17, 2007 · 00:01 UTC#89
Love guys with no useful posts that only come on here to bitch.

Wouldn't the time it took to post the same thing on fifteen consecutive lines been better spent doing something else?
Posted Nov 17, 2007 · 00:15 UTC#90
You should practice what you preach
Posted Nov 17, 2007 · 00:47 UTC#91
Just looked at all the posts you have ever done. One trying to help someone getting scammed and 20 complaining about the same thing. Now look at mine, at least I have helped hundreds of people. Now go away for another six months
Posted Nov 17, 2007 · 00:59 UTC#92
That was a helpful post
Page 4 of 4