Hi Joegr,
If your built in timer allows the radio to operate for 10 minutes after you turn your car off and you turn the ignition back to ACC position before you open the door within this interval, do you even need a battery backup to provide uninterrupted music/GPS during a fillup?
No, I do not have such a timer built into my vehicle, the only timer that exists is one that keeps the courtesy light on for 30 seconds after you open a passenger door, the driver door opening does not start courtesy the timer. None of the cars or trucks I drive have the simple timer feature you describe.
I like others, dont pay with a card(many diesel pumps dont even have a CC swiper on them) thus requiring one to leave the vehicle unattended, with the keys left in the ignition....another safety issue which could lead to your vehicle being stolen, leaving the keys in the ignition wouldn't work for me.
Sorry for using the words "My"...but I wanted to differentiate "My" idea for a design vs. others.
As I admitted the battery was viable but I somehow thought cost played a role in the design, and NOT whether there was any UP time after the vehicle was turned off, after rereading my post...it did sound a bit arrogant, that was not my intention. I was trying to present a design with the least overhead and provide the most safety to readers who are not engineers, a design flexible enough to work for most.
The original poster did say "the battery was overkill", but to others I realize function and not cost is a consideration.
Back to the GELCELs...I said "lead acids without the venting" which is still true, not sure why you are correcting me. The GELCEL battery is sealed non-vented battery as described by the manufacturer. As a matter of properly designed use, they do not vent, external venting is not required in the design, and the manufacturer does not provide a venting line attachment. The GELCEL is recombinant battery requiring positive internal pressure, and if it were to have venting, the battery perfomance and life would be greatly reduced. Its vent seal is only a safety feature to keep the battery from exploding if it is overcharged, or yes short circuited but, as I mentioned in a previous post, one needs to install a fuse on/next to the battery. But under nomal circumstances they do not vent as opposed to the lead acid car wet cell battery which does require venting to the outside of the vehicle at all times to allow hydrogen to escape during normal charging. Wet cell car batteries mounted within the interior of the vehicle all provide a vent line attached directly to the battery for external venting to the outside. Most car batteries also require an upright mounting position, while the GELCEL mounting position is not demanded by the manufacturer of the GELCEL(of course depending on terminal configuaration). Even NICADs will vent if they are improperly charged but like the GELCEL are not considered vented batteries.