Have any of you experienced the Bluetooth quality in the Alpine INA-W910 or the INA-W910BT? Is it any better than the Pioneer? If so, what are the downsides to the Alpine in other areas vs. the Pioneer?
The only downsides I've heard so far:
1. Nav has 6m POI's vs. 12m in the Pioneer
2. No VR at all
3. Interface is less intuitive (this is subjective with some people preferring the Alpine UI and others preferring the Pioneer)
4. No MusicSphere app (I have to admit that I really like the MusicSphere app)
Given the different areas that we can compare, how does the INA-W900BT/910 compare in:
1. Bluetooth
2. Navigation
3. iPod Music Control
4. XM/Sirius
5. HD Radio
6. Sound quality overall given the same speakers
Thanks a lot
Tamir
I can comment on the W900. I have an AVIC Z1, INA-W900, and now an AVIC Z130BT. I originally bought the 900 because I wasn't happy with Pioneer's interface on the Z1, in hindsight I should have bought the Z110(current model at the time). I HATE the Alpine unit. I'm not hating for the sake of hating, I used to be pro-alpine everything but they've really gone downhill lately. I'll touch on each of your points specifically so I don't just end up ranting about it.
1. Nav has 6m POI's vs. 12m in the Pioneer - I don't really use POI's, but I find even the Pioneer lacking in my area, so I can only imagine how bad the Alpine would be if I turned them on.
2. No VR at all - Really annoying, especially for making phone calls
3. Interface is less intuitive - The Alpine interface is bad, really bad. It feels like they had 2 groups building their software, one on audio, one on nav. They don't flow at all. From the nav screen all you can do is nav stuff, from the audio screen all you can do is audio, well except see a stupid compass or your next turn(in the form of an arrow). Switching between them takes waaay longer than it should, but it re-loads the nav again every time you switch back to it. Want to change songs while looking at your map? Can't do it. you have to go to the audio screen and press the soft button(on screen) to change tracks. It's the only way unless you have steering wheel controls(which I don't). The menus look different between audio and nav (yes there are two separate menus), there are two separate setup menus and some settings are global (the entire unit) so unless you know the unit very well you have to check both menus for what you're trying to find. Map screen feels very low resolution for the screen quality. Audio screen looks great, but you can only change the colour of the background, no image selection. Want to change the map from day to night? You can't. It bases "night" on your location and when the sun sets. Leaves a nice bright blinding screen in darkness sometimes with nothing you can do about it. Same with dimmer. There's no illumination lead, it has a light sensor on the front that will dim the display if you're in darkness, but it's not sensitive enough so it is usually too bright. It's a good looking deck with some good features, but the software wasn't ready for release. Not sure if they've fixed it for the 910, but I wouldn't hold my breath. 4. No MusicSphere app (I have to admit that I really like the MusicSphere app) - Haven't used it yet, but sounds similar to Genius on my iDevice.
Given the different areas that we can compare, how does the INA-W900BT/910 compare in:
1. Bluetooth - ANYTHING is better than the AVIC right now. Sticking my head out the window while talking on my phone would sound better than the AVIC, so this is no contest.
2. Navigation - other than the visual differences between maps and interfaces, I'd imagine they work the same. I don't usually use it very much.
3. iPod Music Control - Both are very fast, but the Pioneer is much more intuitive and visually appealing. The alpine can be cumbersome in the menus trying to find what you want, but they both search fast and display info much better than my Z1.
4. XM/Sirius - Don't use, so I don't know
5. HD Radio - Z130 supposedly has HD built in, but there aren't any stations near me that support it so I can't comment
6. Sound quality overall given the same speakers - I haven't had both units installed in the same vehicle, but I can say the Alpine sounded WAY better initially. There was less fiddling to get it dialed in, and it also has less settings. For more settings you can upgrade with an Imprint add on module, but it sounds good even without. On the Z130 I've gotten it into the same ballpark (different vehicle could be the cause as well) It's just taken alot more tuning and fiddling with settings (which there are a lot of)
Overall I'd choose the Pioneer 100 times out of 100 over the Alpine.