Diaftia's menu poll. Hybrid mod users need your feedback

[diaftia]

***EDIT*** Check page 2 for what the new menu would look like.

 

So I have had some people say they like the old version better that keeper redesigned and I have had some say they like the new version better. If you are a user of either or both can you take a vote here and let me know which system you prefer?

 

Here is the old style (Pros: easy to use, easy to mod and easy to add icons to; Cons: covers whole map when up):

 

 

 

New style (Pro's: Doesn't cover the map when up; Cons: harder to modify for n00bs):

 

[keeper22]

Well I am a bit biased but I like the larger buttons.

[tmac505]

Hey Diaftia, your work just keeps getting better & better. I voted for the older larger style; for me its just easier to use while moving. If we were using the stock version we would have to hit menu and deal with all of that so the older larger style is still a vast improvement and the map is only hidden for a short period of time. Thanks, just my two cents.

[diaftia]

Excellent! Thanks for the feedback guys. My thoughts are that if I do go with the larger buttons I might work on some transparency for the background. But then you go into the situation where you have to hide everything that is on the map and then unhide when things are selected. Can get ugly. We'll see though.

 

Lets keep those votes coming in.

[boots]

I like the old style best. It's just more visually appealing to me. The big buttons are nice because my big fingers can push them while I'm driving without accidentally missing, haha!

[FourG]

Ditto on the big icons. Small targets are just too tough to hit when you're driving (example: I've modded copy of your mod to make the next turn icon to be the nav mute instead, since it's big and closest to me and what I use the most in the map). Mind you, most of the quick menus shouldn't be used while driving period, but smaller targets make for less accuracy when stopped at the light.

[diaftia]

Ditto on the big icons. Small targets are just too tough to hit when you're driving (example: I've modded copy of your mod to make the next turn icon to be the nav mute instead, since it's big and closest to me and what I use the most in the map). Mind you, most of the quick menus shouldn't be used while driving period, but smaller targets make for less accuracy when stopped at the light.

 

Thanks for the feedback. Actually, did you vote in the poll above? There are four for big icons on the thread so far but the poll still says three.

[Bman69]

I like the old style best. It's just more visually appealing to me. The big buttons are nice because my big fingers can push them while I'm driving without accidentally missing, haha!

 

I agree with this completely, I dont have very large fingers but the bigger buttons are nice while driving and bumping around you dont miss and mess up while driving causing a bigger distraction

 

I know some people think this covers the whole screen but why does that matter? it's only for a few seconds which is not a big deal

 

 

I feel the large icons look more professional as well as being easier to use

 

Let's hope enough users agree so we can get the old style back in this mod

 

 

 

Thanks diaftia for making this poll I really appreciate it

[jmuenni]

Give me the small icons!!! Doesn't hide the map!

[Bman69]

Give me the small icons!!! Doesn't hide the map!

 

Why does it matter if it covers the map? if you already have a route you dont need to see it when it speaks when to turn and which street

[Dozer.hh]

I think the big ones prevent touching the wrong button and you don't have to be that much focused on teh screen while driving a little bit faster ! Noone is driving on rails I think!

 

So I prefer the big ones!

[tmac505]

Alex I wonder if it would be possible to enlarge the menu button on the map screen if you decide to do the large icon thing. I'm guessing you might be limited in size when using the quick menu small icons so everything fits on the screen, but may be able to double the size of the button with the older larger setup. Just a thought on improving the usability for us folks with big fat fingers. Thanks.

[diaftia]

Alex I wonder if it would be possible to enlarge the menu button on the map screen if you decide to do the large icon thing. I'm guessing you might be limited in size when using the quick menu small icons so everything fits on the screen, but may be able to double the size of the button with the older larger setup. Just a thought on improving the usability for us folks with big fat fingers. Thanks.

 

 

Trust me... I am 6'3" and have large hands myself so I know its a little tough. I have already doubled that button from the size it originally was when the quick menu first came out. But yes, if I don't have to account for the quick menu I get the entire left side of the screen back when not in route and should be able to make it larger. Even the in route button is currently slightly larger than the not in route button. What I will probably do is make it a transparent background button that has a touch point that is twice the size of what the button actually looks like.

[Cal3867]

I am currently using the new small style but I would prefer the old one with larger buttons myself. I think for overall functionality & safety its a better choice. While you may have more options available with fewer button taps on the small style; you have to focus more to see what the heck your selecting. So what if the map gets covered for a few seconds, I could probably get around faster with the larger buttons. Like most others have said, the larger ones would be a better choice IMO.

[bryvale]

I like the small quick menu. I like the ability to look at my options and still see the map screen. Maybe if the large buttons were transparent with no background I would change over. Either way modders out there are making great improvements to the system.